
Emergence of Conscious Consumption and the BDS Movement
As we march forward in the relentless pursuit of technological progress, consumerism has transformed into a culture of instant gratification and fast-paced living. Suffice it to say, if something does not happen at the touch of a button or within a split second, it almost always immediately loses our attention.
Yet, amidst this landscape of convenience, the concept of Conscious Consumption emerges as a shift in consumer behavior. This philosophy emphasises mindful purchasing decisions, encouraging consumers to consider the broader implications of their buying habits. It advocates for a lifestyle of intentional living, where quality and ethics supersede quantity, convenience, and cost.[1] Beyond promoting environmental sustainability, this approach also involves championing fair labour practices and supporting small-scale or local producers.[2]
In a similar vein, the Boycott, Divestment, and Sanctions (BDS) movement offers a strategic framework for individuals to align their consumer choices with their ethical and political values. Launched in 2005 by Palestinian civil society groups, the BDS movement seeks to leverage economic and political pressure to compel Israel to adhere to international law and end its occupation of Palestinian territories. By encouraging consumers to boycott Israeli products or companies involved in the violation of Palestinian rights, divest from companies supporting Israeli policies, and impose sanctions on the Israeli state, BDS presents a non-violent yet powerful tool for challenging systemic injustices.
Recent developments in the BDS movement in Malaysia
The BDS movement in Malaysia has steadily gained traction in the public sphere over many years, demonstrating a growing impact on public opinion and corporate behaviour. Initially, the movement concentrated on high-profile targets like McDonald’s, Starbucks, and Nestlé, leveraging these well-known companies as symbols to spotlight the Palestinian cause and rally public support.
As public awareness grew, the movement expanded to include a broader range of products and companies associated with the Israeli occupation. Major incidents in Malaysia, such as the backlash against GRAB and ZUS Coffee, as well as criticism of local celebrities, led to public apologies and significant donations to Palestine. Additionally, JCORP’s involvement with KFC ignited a national discussion about the disconnect between local franchises and their international activities, prompting BDS Malaysia to issue a statement clarifying that KFC was never on their boycott list.[3]
Moreover, the issue of BlackRock’s investments in Malaysian MNCs has sparked great debate in Parliament and among the public. Globally, celebrities and businesses are under deep scrutiny, not only for their explicit positions on the Palestinian cause but also for their perceived indifference or superficial responses to such critical issues.
As awareness of these issues grows, the emergence of digital resources showcases the increasing demand for informed and ethical decision-making. Tools such as ‘Boycat’ and ‘No Thanks’ have become valuable aids in tracking corporate practices and offering alternatives for those wishing to align their purchases with human rights and social justice causes.
Both the BDS movement and the principles of Conscious Consumption call on consumers to recognise the political and ethical dimensions of their purchasing decisions. This perspective challenges the traditional notion of consumption as a purely economic activity, instead positioning it as an instrument for social and political change.
Challenging traditional economic models
For economists who adhere to traditional growth paradigms, these movements may be perceived as a challenge to conventional thinking. Traditional economic frameworks often equate economic growth with increased consumer spending, operating under the assumption that mass consumption drives greater economic activity and prosperity.
However, Conscious Consumption, alongside movements like BDS and concepts such as the Circular Economy, advocates for a different path. A prime example of this shift is the emergence of Certified B Corporations (B Corps), which prioritise purpose alongside profit. This certification reflects a company’s commitment to making decisions that not only generate returns for shareholders but also create positive outcomes for people, communities, and the planet. In Malaysia, there are currently 16 B Corps spanning various sectors.[4]
These ‘alternative’ approaches suggest that adopting mindful consumption practices and focusing on sustainability can yield profound socio-economic benefits. By making deliberate and intentional purchasing decisions, these movements demonstrate that less can indeed be more, emphasising quality, ethics, and environmental sustainability over excessive quantity.
Spotlight on homegrown products
The BDS movement has understandably raised concerns about the potential loss of jobs, particularly with the closure of several McDonald’s and Starbucks locations. The impact on livelihoods is a serious consideration and should never be taken lightly. However, alongside this movement, there has been a notable shift toward supporting local businesses in Malaysia.
As consumers become more mindful of their purchasing decisions, many are turning to homegrown goods and services. This shift is empowering local brands to gain visibility and market share, with Malaysian F&B brands, local fashion labels, and even skincare and body products stepping up as viable alternatives.
For instance, ZUS Coffee has quickly gained popularity by offering affordable drinks and simplifying the ordering process through its mobile app. The brand has also collaborated with local artists, showcasing their artwork and strengthening ties to Malaysian culture. Similarly, Bask Bear has distinguished itself by promoting the conservation of the Malayan Sun Bear, integrating social responsibility into its brand. The company incorporates Aren palm sugar, a traditionally sourced ingredient from Sabah and Sarawak, highlighting Malaysia’s agricultural heritage while providing consistent income to local farmers.[5]
The movement has shone a spotlight on local businesses that might otherwise struggle to compete in a market dominated by international brands. It is essential to remember that local businesses also provide employment and sustain livelihoods. With the right opportunities and visibility, they can not only offer alternatives but potentially superior products. While the loss of jobs due to the boycott is very concerning, this movement also presents an opportunity to spur the growth of local enterprises and create better prospects for Malaysians.
We must remember that no one can be expected to make perfect changes to their consumption habits overnight, especially when international products are so ingrained in daily life. However, ethical consumption is not about perfection—it is about making small, meaningful decisions that collectively contribute to broader change.
Conclusion
In conclusion, the synergy between the principles of Conscious Consumption and the goals of the BDS movement forms a compelling model of ethical consumerism. It challenges individuals to critically evaluate the far-reaching impacts of their purchasing decisions.
Contrary to the common misconception that change requires individual perfection, mindful consumption emphasises the collective efforts of entire societies, focusing on small but meaningful incremental changes. Through intentional measures, consumers can contribute to a more just and sustainable world. This approach benefits not only the environment and fair labour practices but also aligns with broader efforts to advance human rights and social justice.
References
- B Corps in Malaysia. (n.d.). Retrieved from B Corp Asia: https://www.bcorpasia.org/malaysia
- Cory Ames. (24 August, 2022). How to Be a Conscious Consumer. Retrieved from Cory Ames: https://coryames.com/conscious-consumerism/
- Harty, B. (n.d.). What Is Conscious Consumption, And Why Is It Important? Retrieved from The Momentum: https://www.themomentum.com/articles/what-is-conscious-consumption-and-why-is-it-important#:~:text=Conscious%20consumption%20simply%20means%20to,world%20you%20want%20to%20see
- Palestine Solidarity Campaign. (n.d.). Boycott, Divestment & Sanctions (BDS) Movement. Retrieved from Palestine Solidarity Campaign: https://palestinecampaign.org/campaigns/bds-2/
- Suhaidi, N. (12 January, 2024). Are boycotts impacting homegrown brands positively? Retrieved from The Malaysian Reserve : https://themalaysianreserve.com/2024/01/12/are-boycotts-impacting-homegrown-brands-positively/